At a Glance
- Keller Independent School District mandates employees to inform parents of children’s gender identities within 24 hours.
- The policy was unanimously approved by the Keller ISD Board of Trustees.
- Critics argue the policy exposes students to potential harm from unaccepting parents.
- Supporters believe it aligns with societal norms and community values.
Keller ISD’s Policy Requirements
The Keller Independent School District (ISD) in Texas has enacted a new policy that forbids the use of pronouns that do not match the gender specified on students’ birth certificates. Employees are required to notify parents of any student’s request to use different pronouns or names within 24 hours. Additionally, the policy mandates notification if a student seeks to use school facilities that do not correspond with their biological sex.
The policy was unanimously approved by the Keller ISD Board of Trustees. Supporters of the policy argue that it simplifies interpersonal interactions, reinforces societal norms, and aligns with community values. The policy also prohibits employees from promoting or using pronouns that differ from a student’s biological sex.
Texas school district adopts policy that teachers must use pronouns consistent with students' biological sex https://t.co/gZxO5T3pvV
— Fox News (@FoxNews) August 24, 2024
Arguments Against the Policy
The policy has sparked substantial opposition from students, parents, and community members. Many argue that the policy disregards the genuine experiences and identities of transgender students. Critics, including the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Texas, believe the policy could endanger students by exposing them to potential abuse or neglect from unaccepting parents.
High school seniors Kennedy Schultz and Madison Hickman voiced strong opposition, describing the policy as harmful and promoting fear and isolation. Schultz stated, “Every day I walk into a school and myself and my peers are suffering. It seems like more and more the school district is prioritizing budget cuts and a political agenda over the health of its students.”
Texas School District Bans Pronouns that Do Not Match Birth Certificate https://t.co/wUpIqDD504
— Freya 🇺🇸 (@JustSay23848309) August 25, 2024
Contrasts with California’s Approaches
This policy contrasts sharply with actions in California, where a recent law was signed that prohibits schools from requiring parental notification of a child’s gender identity. Some California school districts are challenging the new law, advocating for parental notification rights. Critics of California’s approach believe it undermines parental rights, while supporters argue it protects vulnerable students.
As debates continue, a March survey by Noble Predictive Insights found that about 60% of voters nationwide oppose schools allowing students to use preferred names or pronouns without parental notification. This survey underscores the nation’s divided stance on how schools should balance traditional values with contemporary understandings of gender identities.
Sources
Texas school district under fire for ‘unsafe’ gender pronoun policy
Texas School District Bans Pronouns that Do Not Match Birth Certificate
A Texas School District Restricts Personal Pronoun Choice
A Texas school district approved limits on books, critical race theory and gender identity